Chapter 2

“Get away from them.”
Vanessa’s voice came down the ladder sharp and low. Her phone glowed against her palm, the call still going through.
“They’re confused,” she said. “You’ve been gone twelve years. You don’t know what they’re like now.”
Dad’s shoulders tightened beside me. Mom’s hand, still cold in mine, drew away—not from me this time, but toward the shadows under the shelves.
“Come down and ask them,” I said.
“I’m not coming down there while you’re upsetting them.”
“You’re the one who locked them in.”
Vanessa’s face changed. Just for a second, the mask slipped, and I saw anger—not surprise, not shame. Then she glanced at the phone and softened her mouth as if someone on the other end could see her.
“They’re safe,” she said. “I’m the only one who’s been keeping them safe.”
Dad pushed himself upright against the wall. His knees shook, but his voice didn’t.
“I found the papers.”
Vanessa’s eyes snapped to him.
“Dad,” she said, warning in the single syllable.
“Loan papers,” he continued. “You said they were for repairs. They weren’t.”
My stomach turned. “What papers?”
“Nothing,” Vanessa said. “He doesn’t understand what he’s reading.”
“I understood enough,” Dad said. “I asked her what she’d done, and she—”
“Stop.” Vanessa lowered the phone. “You’re making this worse.”
“For whom?” I asked.
She reached for the hatch.
I lunged up the ladder, one hand catching the edge before she could pull it down. The wood slammed against my palm. Vanessa jerked back, and the phone nearly fell from her hand.
“Let go.”
“Not until they’re out.”
“You have no idea what you’re doing.”
“I know they’re in a cellar.”
“They wanted to be left alone.”
Mom made a small sound behind me. I looked down. She was staring at Vanessa, her face pale and still.
“That isn’t true,” she said.
Vanessa’s jaw worked. The woman who’d served me Christmas dinner a few hours earlier—the one who’d smiled when she lied about our parents visiting a dead uncle—stood at the hatch with one hand braced on the wood.
“You’re tired,” Vanessa told Mom. “You don’t need to get involved.”
“I’ve been involved the whole time.”
Dad tried to climb the ladder. His boot slipped on a rung.
I turned, catching him beneath the arm. He winced as his weight came down against me. Above us, Vanessa seized the hatch again.
“Michael, get out of this house,” she said. “Now.”
“He’s not going anywhere,” Dad said.
“Dad, don’t.” Vanessa’s voice broke on the last word. She swallowed and looked back at the phone. “I’m handling it.”
The call connected. A tinny voice answered, too faint for me to make out.
Vanessa turned her shoulder toward us. “I need help at the house,” she said. “My brother’s here, and he’s—”
She stopped.
The pause told me she was choosing which version of me to give the stranger.
Mom moved first. She reached for my wrist, slipped something cold into my palm, and closed my fingers around it. A small brass key.
Then she pointed past the shelves.
I leaned close. “What is it?”
“Your grandfather’s passage,” she whispered. “Behind the boxes.”
I remembered Grandpa’s stories about a service crawlspace he’d built when the garage had been added. I’d been a kid then, too young to know whether his secret-tunnel tales were real. There had been a narrow door behind the shelves, though; I remembered that much. Vanessa had stacked paint cans and cartons in front of it.
“Can you get there?” I asked Mom.
She nodded once.
Vanessa glanced down and saw us moving. Her expression hardened.
“Don’t you dare.”
She thrust the hatch downward. I shoved back with both hands. The wood shuddered between us, cutting off the light from the kitchen in a jagged wedge.
“Michael, get up here!” she shouted.
“No.”
Dad clung to my shoulder, breath rasping close to my ear. I held the hatch with one arm while Mom edged along the wall, one careful step at a time. A shelf rattled as she reached the stacked boxes.
“Mom, take your time.”
“Don’t talk to me like I’m made of glass.”
It was the first spark of her old voice I’d heard all night. It steadied me more than any promise could have.
I let the hatch drop just enough to make Vanessa believe she’d won. She hauled it toward her. At the same moment, Dad shifted his weight against the ladder and I slipped away, ducking beneath the opening before she could close it.
Vanessa lunged for my shirt. Her fingers caught the fabric at my shoulder.
“You’re making this dangerous,” she hissed.
“It already is.”
I pulled free. She stumbled against the pantry cabinet, and her phone clattered to the floor. I heard the voice on the line calling out, but she snatched the device before I could see the screen.
Behind me, Mom had cleared a path to the old door. The brass key fit the rusted lock. She turned it with both hands until something inside clicked.
The door opened an inch.
Cold air breathed through the gap, carrying the smell of dust and motor oil.
Dad stared at it. “I thought they filled this in.”
“So did I,” Mom said.
The passage was scarcely wider than my shoulders. I went in first, crawling over packed earth and splintered boards, then turned to help Dad through. He paused at the threshold, one hand pressed against the frame.
“Don’t let her tell you I agreed to any of this,” he said.
“I won’t.”
“I mean it, Michael. Don’t decide you know the whole story just because you got here tonight.”
The words found their mark. I had spent twelve years sending money and calling that care. I had no right to mistake the cellar for the only thing I’d missed.
“I’ll listen,” I said. “When you’re ready.”
Dad studied my face, then ducked into the passage.
Mom followed him. I went last, easing the door closed behind us. In the cramped dark, I heard Vanessa moving above, the hatch striking its frame once, then again.
The passage sloped upward. My knees scraped the dirt, and Dad’s breath caught whenever the ceiling dipped low. Twice we stopped to let him rest. Each time, he insisted we keep going before his hands had stopped trembling.
At the end, I found a wooden panel and pressed my shoulder against it. It gave with a groan, opening into the attached garage behind a row of old shelves.
We emerged beside a stack of snow tires. The garage smelled of gasoline, cold metal, and the faint cedar scent of Dad’s workbench. For a moment, none of us moved.
Then Mom gripped my sleeve. “She’ll tell them you took us.”
A thud sounded from the kitchen side of the house.
“Then we tell them the truth,” I said.
Dad looked at me, tired and wary. “The truth has to be more than what you saw.”
Before I could answer, an engine growled outside.
I crept to the garage window. In the wash of the porch light, Vanessa stood in the drive with her phone pressed to her ear. Her gaze swept over the house, then fixed on the garage.
May you like
She pointed straight at us.
Headlights turned into the drive.