Chapter 5: Mediation In A Church Basement
They sent us to the county annex, which turned out to be the basement under the Methodist church on Main. I remember the smell first, coffee and old carpet and the faint gas heat kicking on. The mediator met us at the bottom of the stairs. She was a woman in her forties with a navy cardigan and a clipboard, and she walked us past a room where folding chairs were stacked against a cinderblock wall.
My dad had his light blue shirt tucked in tight that day and his hair combed flat. He kept his hands in front of him like he was trying to keep them still. My mom was already there, sitting at a long table with a box of tissues in the middle. She wore a gray sweater I knew from school pick-up. She didn't look at me right away, she looked at the mediator, and I could tell she was trying not to cry either.
The mediator pulled out two more chairs and said the same rules to all of us at once. This was voluntary but court-ordered, she said. No interrupting. No bringing up things outside this room to punish anyone later. We were there to see if we could make a parenting plan without the judge having to decide for us. She said we would start together for ten minutes, then break into separate rooms, and that I would stay with Ms. Ramirez, the child advocate, in the playroom down the hall. She spoke slow and even, and she wrote PARENTS - LISTEN on a little whiteboard like we were in school.
My dad nodded at everything. He folded his hands and said, "Absolutely. I just want what's calm for her." His voice was different from court, quieter, careful. My mom didn't nod. She kept her hands around her coffee cup and said, "I want what's true." The mediator wrote that down too and didn't pick a side.
Ms. Ramirez knelt down to my level and asked if I wanted to see the playroom. It was really just another Sunday school room with a low table, crayons, and a rug with the alphabet on it. There was a dollhouse with missing shingles and a basket of plastic food. She sat on the floor, not at the table, so I sat on the floor too. She didn't ask me about court. She just let me line up the little wooden people and asked what night was like at Dad's.
I told her about the TV being loud so I couldn't sleep and about how the lock on the bathroom didn't work. I didn't mean to say anything important. I was moving a little plastic bed around. I said at Dad's I slept on the couch when his friend came over because my room was where they sat and talked, and that I had to get my own cereal in the morning because he was still asleep and the milk was sometimes warm. Ms. Ramirez asked what time I usually got up, and I said before the sun, when the heat clicked, and that I watched cartoons with no sound so I wouldn't wake anyone.
She wrote it down in a small notebook without making a big deal of it, but I saw her underline something twice. Later I realized it was the same gap the caseworker had flagged after visiting Dad's apartment — that he'd told them I had my own bedroom and a set bedtime and breakfast together.
Down the hall, the mediator had brought my parents back together. When Ms. Ramirez and I were called back in, my dad had a piece of paper he'd been writing on. He slid it across the table toward my mom like it was a gift. He said he'd drop the request for full custody if we could all agree on a simple statement. Fifty-fifty time, no more court dates, no more strangers in our homes. He looked at me when he said it, soft for the first time that day.
"All she has to do," he said, "is say she was confused about that one night. That she misremembered. Kids do. She's six. No one would hold it against her."
The room went very quiet except for the heater humming. My mom's mouth tightened. She didn't touch the paper. She looked at the mediator and said, "That's not confusion. That's what she told the judge she saw."
The mediator turned to Ms. Ramirez, and Ms. Ramirez knelt again and asked me, quiet, if I wanted to change anything I'd said before. She said no one would be mad either way, but it had to be my words.
I felt my hands get cold. I thought about the couch and the warm milk and the bathroom lock. I shook my head. I said, "No. That happened." My voice was small and it cracked on happened, but I didn't take it back.
My dad's calm slipped just for a second. His jaw went tight and he let out a breath through his nose. He said, "Honey, we're trying to make this easy for you," but he said it to the table, not to me.
May you like
The mediator picked up her pen and wrote for a long time. Then she read it out loud — parties unable to reach agreement, child through advocate declines to retract prior statement, advocate's spontaneous note corroborates previously identified inconsistency regarding overnight routine. She said she'd file the impasse and send us back to the judge for an evidentiary hearing.
Ms. Ramirez squeezed my shoulder as we stood up. My dad left first, up the stairs without waiting.
