Chapter 5 - Lily's Crayon Door
The argument hadn't gotten loud. That was the worst part. Daniel and I stood in the bedroom doorway keeping our voices low while Lily sat at the coffee table in the living room, her little white sneakers tucked under her legs. She had the plastic bin of crayons tipped over and was coloring so hard I could hear the wax scratching paper.
"You need to stop looking for problems in the paperwork," Daniel had whispered, his hand resting on the doorframe like he was blocking me from going back in there. Dust still powdered his white henley at the cuffs.
"I wasn't looking for problems. I was looking for an explanation," I said. "That wall doesn't make sense and you know it."
He opened his mouth, then looked past me at Lily and shut it again. His jaw worked. That tight, restrained tension he'd had since he picked up the hammer was still there.
Lily slid off the couch cushion and came toward us, holding a sheet of printer paper with both hands. She'd been quiet so long I'd almost forgotten she was listening.
"Mommy, look," she said.
I crouched down to her level. The carpet in the living room was the same light beige as the bedroom, afternoon light coming through the front window now, softer than the daylight in our bedroom. I took the paper carefully.
She'd drawn the wardrobe. I recognized it right away - the tall dark rectangle with the little carved swoop on top she'd done in brown, the two doors with circles for handles. Next to it she'd drawn our wall, but she'd colored a big black rectangle right in the middle of it. The black door. She'd pressed so hard the crayon had left wax ridges.
In front of the door were three stick figures. One tall in white, one in red, one small in beige. Us.
Behind the black rectangle, filling the space, was a scribbled shape in dark gray, tall and vertical, with what looked like two dots for eyes near the top. It wasn't detailed. It was just a heavy, looming scribble that went taller than the door itself.
My chest tightened. I kept my voice even.
"Tell me about your picture, sweet pea," I said.
Lily pointed with a chipped pink fingernail. "That's you and me and Daddy. And that's the secret door you found." She tapped the gray scribble. "And that's the man who lives behind it."
Daniel shifted behind me. I felt him go still.
"What man, baby?" I asked. I brushed her hair back from her cheek. She'd pulled her ponytail loose while coloring and blonde strands were stuck to her neck.
"The man I dreamed about," she said softly, like she was telling a secret. "He was behind the wall and he was waiting. He didn't have a face, just tall like this." She stretched her little arm up high. "I heard him when the wardrobe was there."
I swallowed. "You heard him before we moved the wardrobe?"
She nodded. Her eyes flicked toward the bedroom, then back to me. "He was knocking sometimes. I thought you would be mad if I told."
Daniel made a sharp sound. He stepped forward and took the paper right out of my hands.
"Lily, this is just a cartoon," he said. His voice was too loud, too fast. "You watched that show with the monster closet, remember? You drew a monster because you saw it on TV. There's no man. There's no one behind there."
Lily flinched. Her shoulders came up to her ears.
"Daniel," I said quietly.
He didn't look at me. He held the paper up like evidence. "Sweetie, you can't draw stuff like this and scare your mom. It's not real. It's crayons. It's not real, okay? You dreamed it because you ate too much candy before bed."
"We didn't have candy last night," I said.
He finally looked down at me, still crouched on the floor with Lily pressed against my knee. His face was flushed. The dismissal was so quick, so forceful, it didn't sound like reassurance. It sounded like panic. He folded the paper in half, creasing it hard with his thumb.
"Don't fold her drawing," I said, and took it back from him. My fingers were steady but I could feel heat in my cheeks.
Lily's bottom lip trembled. "Is it a bad dream?"
I smoothed the paper out on my lap. The gray scribble had smeared slightly where he'd pressed. I looked at that tall shape, at the two dots she'd made for eyes, and I understood then that it didn't matter if it was a cartoon or a dream or something she'd stitched together from hearing us whisper. To her, that door already had something behind it, and Daniel telling her she was wrong wasn't going to make her feel safe. It was going to teach her not to tell us what scared her.
"No, honey, it's not bad that you drew it," I said. I kept my eyes on her, not on him. "Thank you for showing me. If you dream about it again, you can always tell me, okay? Even if it feels scary."
She nodded and leaned into my shoulder. She smelled like crayons and apple juice.
Daniel exhaled through his nose. "Vanessa, you're making it a thing. She's six. She has nightmares."
"I'm not making it a thing," I said, standing slowly with Lily's hand in mine. I folded the drawing carefully this time and set it on the coffee table instead of tossing it. "I'm listening to her."
We looked at each other over Lily's head. Something in his expression slipped - that anxious micro-expression I'd seen on camera, the way his brows pulled together when he wanted me to stop looking. He wasn't worried about a cartoon. He was worried I'd keep asking.
May you like
I walked Lily back to the couch and sat with her for a minute, letting her pick up the red crayon again. Her hand was small and warm in mine.
I decided right then, with the bedroom door half-open behind us and that dust-covered black knob still waiting in the broken plaster, that I wasn't going to let Daniel narrate this for her. If there was nothing back there, she deserved to see it with me and feel safe again. And if there was something, she deserved a mother who hadn't looked away because her husband told her to. I was going to see behind that door myself.
