Chapter 4
Jonah didn't ask. He placed his hand low on my back and guided me away from the ballroom floor, Dad a step behind us. His palm was warm through the thin fabric of my gown and his fingers pressed just enough to steer.
"Let's talk privately," Jonah said. His voice had gone smooth again, the host voice. "Dressing suite. Quieter."
We moved past the curved staircase with its dark ornate railing. The chandelier light thinned as we left the main room. A side door I had always been told to keep closed was open now, and the hallway beyond was cool and quiet, the marble giving way to a softer rug that muffled our steps. I could hear Dad's dress shoes behind me and the faint rustle of my dress where the thigh slit caught air.
The suite was not large. A vanity with bright bulbs, two armchairs, a full-length mirror in a gilt frame, and a rack of coats no one had touched all night. The air smelled like hairspray and perfume and the faint cleaner they used on the marble.
Jonah let go of me once we were inside.
I didn't mean to look in the mirror, but it was directly in front of me. I saw the whole of it at once and then couldn't look away.
The blue-lavender gown was torn. Not a lot, but enough. The slit that had been cut to show a line of leg was ripped two inches higher, the threads pulled white where the fabric had given. A faint dark smudge marked the hem where it had dragged on the floor. In the bright vanity light every bruise showed. The red mark on my left cheek, the mottled shadows on my shoulders where the straps had dug, the deeper bruise just above my chest that the dress couldn't hide. My wrists had matching ovals.
Jonah saw me seeing it. He crossed to the door we had just come through.
The lock clicked.
It was a small sound, a brass tongue sliding home, but Dad heard it too. Jonah turned the little key once and slipped it into the inner pocket of his tuxedo jacket, patting it flat with his palm. He didn't look at either of us when he did it. He adjusted his jacket at the torso the same way he had by the staircase, eyes briefly closed, like he was settling himself.
"This is my house, my rules," he said, almost gently. "We will calm down in here and then we will go back out."
Dad didn't sit. He stood between me and the door, though Jonah was closer to it. Dad's hands were at his sides, then one hand lifted.
"Elise," he said. His voice was low. "Your wrist."
I had crossed my arms over my chest without thinking, the way I'd stood alone on that debris-strewn floor minutes before. My right wrist was turned out. The bruise there was fresh, red-purple, the exact shape of fingers. Four small ovals on one side, a thumbprint on the other.
Dad stepped closer. He didn't touch me right away. He asked with his eyes first, and I gave a small nod.
He took my forearm lightly, turned it just enough to the light. His breathing changed.
"That matches where he had you," he said. He looked at Jonah. Jonah smiled a little, not unkind, which was worse.
Dad let go, carefully, and pulled his phone from his suit pants. His hand wasn't quite steady.
"I need to take a photo of this," he said to me. "Okay?"
I nodded again. My throat was dry. "Okay."
He held the phone close. The shutter sound was loud in the quiet room. He took one of my right wrist, then turned my left hand over and took another. Then, without asking, he tilted the phone up and got the marks on my shoulder and chest where the gown had slipped. The flash made me blink. In the mirror I watched him work — his mouth tight, his eyes not leaving the marks, his jaw shifting as he swallowed.
Jonah watched too, from by the door. "You don't need to do that," he said.
"I do," Dad said, not looking up. He slipped the phone back into his pocket. "I have them now."
The room felt smaller. I could see both men reflected behind me, Jonah by the locked door with his hand still near his pocket, Dad beside me with his phone now heavy in his pants.
Dad's eyes came back to mine in the mirror.
"Was tonight the first time?" he asked. He said it quietly, so I could answer quietly.
I had lied to him for months by omission. By saying Jonah worked late, by saying I liked staying home, by saying the marks were clumsiness. The lie sat right behind my teeth and then fell apart. I looked at the torn slit again, at the bruises I had covered with makeup that had finally worn off.
"No," I said. My voice was small but clear. "This was not the first night."
May you like
I heard Dad inhale. I didn't turn around. In the mirror I saw Jonah's smirk tighten just a fraction, as if he had expected me to keep that to myself a little longer.
No one moved toward the door. The key stayed in Jonah's pocket. The photos stayed in Dad's phone. And I understood, standing in that bright locked suite in the dress that had remembered everything, that every lock in this house had always been his to turn, not mine.
