Chapter 14 - Boy To Mister
The silence after the officer sat back down felt heavier than any of the words before it. I kept my hands flat on the counsel table and didn't fill it. The microphones picked up the hum of the lights and the soft shift of paper somewhere behind me. My heart was beating hard enough I could feel it in my wrists, but I breathed through my nose and let the record sit the way it was.
The judge wasn't laughing now. He pulled his glasses down and looked at me for a long second, not at my suit or my cuffs, but at my face. When he spoke, his voice had lost that edge for the crowd.
"Mr...." He paused. He didn't know my last name on his tongue, and I saw him glance down at the file to get it right. "Mr. Carter. Stand by for the court."
It was a small thing. Mister instead of boy. I felt it land in my chest anyway. Behind me I heard my mom let out a breath she must have been holding for an hour.
The attorney pushed his chair back and stood. For most of the hearing he'd been watching the judge, waiting for a cue. Now he looked at me, then at the bench.
"Your Honor," he said, "for the record... counsel will concede the documents held by the witness should be reviewed. Not dismissed sight unseen." He adjusted his tie. "If the Court is inclined to take a brief recess to examine them, the state has no objection."
I didn't turn around, but I could picture my mom. Light blue scrubs, stethoscope tucked in her pocket, those white papers with the Harvard University header she'd carried in from her shift. She'd been holding them so tight her knuckles had gone pale. Now I heard the paper ease, a soft crinkle as her grip loosened.
The judge leaned back. The seal behind him caught the light. The flag in the corner didn't move. He tapped his pen once against the bench, then set it down.
"The Court," he said slowly, "made remarks at the outset that... were not consistent with the presumption this courtroom owes every defendant." He didn't look out at the gallery when he said it. He looked at the recorder, making sure it got captured. "The defendant has elected to represent himself. The Court will honor that election."
My throat went dry. I nodded once because I didn't trust my voice yet.
He continued, "There is an evidentiary proffer on the table. A timeline issue has been raised. No rebuttal has been offered." He glanced at the officer, then back to me. "Procedure requires the Court to take a fair look before ruling."
I let my hands come together in front of me. The metal of the handcuff bracelet was cool against my skin. I didn't raise them. I just waited.
"Here's what we're going to do," the judge said. His tone was plain now, tired, formal. "The Court will take a brief recess — fifteen minutes — to review the papers in chambers. The witness will surrender them to the bailiff for that limited purpose." He held up a finger. "Not admitted. For review only. We'll reconvene in this same courtroom for argument on admissibility."
My mom made a small sound behind me. Not a sob. More like air leaving. I wanted to turn and tell her it was okay, but I kept my eyes on the bench because I knew this was the moment to stay steady.
"Mr. Carter," the judge said, "you will remain at counsel table. Do you understand the Court's order?"
I cleared my throat. "Yes, Your Honor. I understand."
He gave a short nod and lifted his gavel, but he didn't bring it down hard. Just a tap. "Court stands in recess for fifteen minutes."
May you like
The attorney sat down and started stacking his files without looking at me. The officer stepped forward to take the papers from my mom, and I finally turned enough to see her hands shake as she passed them over. She wiped at her cheek with the back of her wrist and mouthed, you did good. I didn't smile. I just held her eyes for a second so she'd know I heard her.
The judge stood and walked off the bench through the side door. The room stayed seated until he was gone.
