Chapter 7
I didn't see Dad's face through the door. I heard him. Wood was thin enough to hear breathing on other side. Cold came up from concrete through my socks and Teresa's hand was still on my head.
"Why is she a problem?" Dad said. His voice was closer now, right against the brass plate. Didn't sound loud. Sounded tired.
Melanie answered fast. Heels clicked once on wood floor like she stepped closer to door.
"She was defiant in the hallway," she said. "I asked her to walk properly. She pulled away. She made a scene. Right before guests arrive."
I remembered her grip on my collar. How my sneakers squeaked trying not to go. Teresa's fingers tightened a little on my shoulder. She didn't make a sound at first.
Dad didn't answer right away. I heard his hand on the doorknob. Metal rattled. Locked.
"Defiant," he repeated.
"Yes," Melanie said. "You weren't here. You didn't see it. I told her, you want to act like a problem, then get out of my sight. I'm trying to keep order in this house. We have the foundation dinner Thursday. People will be here. I can't have her running wild while I'm responsible for everything."
Her voice stayed calm. Too calm. Like she was explaining a schedule, not why I was locked in a basement.
Teresa leaned down. Her mouth was next to my ear. Her whisper was so quiet I felt her breath more than heard words.
"That didn't happen, sweetheart," she whispered. "You didn't do anything wrong. You said sorry. I heard you."
I nodded against her apron. My throat hurt from crying but I wasn't crying now. I was listening.
Outside, Dad breathed out hard.
"Order," he said. "You locked an eight-year-old in a storage room for order."
"It's not a storage room, it's the basement level," Melanie said. "It's safe. It's temporary. She needs to learn there are consequences. And Teresa inserted herself. I said fine, stay with her then. That was her choice."
Teresa closed her eyes for second. Shook her head just enough I saw it. She didn't whisper again yet.
Dad knocked once, knuckles against wood, not pounding this time.
"Melanie, where's the key?" he asked.
Pause. I heard her shift weight.
"I have it," she said. "And I'm not going to be undermined in my own home. Every time I set a boundary you let her undo it. If you open that door right now you tell her she can disrespect me and get away with it."
"She's eight," Dad said.
"And I'm the one here all day managing this house, managing her school calls, managing your foundation image while you're gone with your bag," she said. Her voice finally cracked a little. "Do you know what people say if our house looks chaotic? If she acts out at the gala? I do this so you don't have to think about it."
I didn't know what gala meant. Sounded like a party for grown-ups. Teresa's hand rubbed my back in small circles.
Dad was quiet so long I thought he'd left. Then he spoke lower.
"This isn't about Thursday," he said. "You said 'learn your place.' I heard you through the door."
Melanie didn't answer right away. I heard faint jingle, maybe keys in her hand.
"I meant they both need to understand roles," she said. "Teresa works for us. Claire needs structure. It's not personal."
Behind the door, Teresa finally spoke loud enough to carry. Not shouting. Clear.
"Mr. Deaken, we're cold," she said. "Claire's been down here enough today."
Something in Dad's breathing changed. Small sharp inhale.
"Enough today?" he said.
Melanie cut in fast. "She's exaggerating. Teresa is dramatic when she's corrected."
But Dad didn't respond to Melanie. He spoke to door.
"Teresa, how long?" he asked.
Teresa looked down at me. I looked up at her. She squeezed my hand once before answering.
May you like
"Long enough to know this isn't first time she was called a problem," she said quietly.
Outside, no one moved. I heard Dad's palm flat against door. Melanie's heels didn't click. Hallway stayed silent except for fluorescent light humming above us and my own breathing coming back fast.
