Chapter 6: How Do You Know That
The back hallway at the Whitmore was narrow and too warm, lined with cream paneling that didn't quite match the ballroom and a row of recessed lights that buzzed faintly. A service cart with stacked dessert plates had been shoved against one wall. Nora stood beside it with her arms crossed tight over her navy dress, and I closed the door behind us. The music from the ballroom was muffled now, just bass and the murmur of a hundred people being told to stay where they were.
I didn't raise my voice. I didn't have to.
"How do you know that was my glass specifically?" I asked her.
She looked at me and then down the hall toward the service entrance where a sheriff's deputy was standing with his radio crackling. Her breathing was shallow. She'd taken her shoes off at some point and was holding them in one hand.
"Because I watched them set the table," she said. "I watched Vivian."
"That isn't what I asked."
She swallowed. I could see her throat move.
"I mean, how did you know it was poisoned," I said. "Not that something looked strange. Not that you had a bad feeling. You said 'It's poisoned' like you knew exactly what was in it. So how."
Nora set her shoes down carefully on the carpet, lining them up heel to heel. A small, unnecessary adjustment. Her hands were shaking when she let go.
"I followed her," she said.
My jaw tightened. The hallway air felt stale, smelling of coffee grounds and melted butter from the kitchen two doors down.
"You followed Vivian?"
"I heard her on the phone," she said quickly, like she'd been waiting to get the sentence out. "Right before the toasts. She stepped out onto the terrace. I was bringing the seating chart back to the coordinator and I heard her. She said, 'Tonight he signs everything over.' Just like that. Flat. Like a transaction."
I stared at her. The chandelier light from the ballroom cut a thin line under the door behind me.
"Who was she talking to?" I asked.
"I don't know. I couldn't see her screen. She was speaking low, turned away. But Daniel, you have to understand, I've worked for you for three years. I've seen that tone. That's the tone people use when they're closing something they don't want anyone to hear."
I took a step closer. Not threatening, just close enough that she couldn't look past me.
"So you decided to watch her."
"Yes."
"For how long?"
"Five minutes. Maybe ten." Her eyes flicked to mine and away. "She came back in, went straight to the head table. The glasses were already poured. Yours was on the right, by your plate. The one with the little fold in the napkin. She walked past it, and then she doubled back."
Her hands came up again, unconsciously miming it.
"What did you see her do?" I asked.
Nora's fingers hovered over an imaginary rim. "She put her hand over your glass. Just for a second. Her fingers were over the rim and she made this motion, like this, with her fingertip."
She stirred the air.
"Did you see anything in her hand? Powder? A pill? The bottle?"
The pause lasted too long.
"Nora."
"No," she said. The word came out small. "I didn't see powder dissolve. I didn't see her drop anything. I saw her fingers go over the rim and stir. That was it. And then she pulled her hand back and walked away like nothing happened."
The hallway buzz seemed to get louder. I felt the weight drop in my stomach, the kind of slow, heavy realization that doesn't hit all at once.
"You told a ballroom full of people my champagne was poisoned," I said, keeping my voice level, "and you didn't actually see poison go into it."
"I saw enough," she said, and there was a sudden heat in her voice, a defensiveness that cracked through the fear. "You know what that bottle is in her dressing room. The lorazepam. Crushed, it would dissolve in champagne and you wouldn't taste it. You would just get sleepy and everyone would think you'd celebrated too hard."
"Did you see the bottle before tonight?"
"No."
"Did you see her carry it to the table?"
"No. But Daniel, why else would she—"
"Stop," I said. It wasn't loud, but she stopped. I pressed my thumb hard against the seam of my tuxedo pants. My white pocket square felt ridiculous now. "You didn't see it go in. You saw fingers over a rim and you inferred the rest. Is that accurate?"
She looked like she wanted to argue, then nodded once. Her eyes were wet but she wasn't crying.
"Yes," she whispered. "That's accurate."
I stepped back and leaned against the wall. The paneling was cool through my shirt. On the other side of the door, a deputy was saying something about keeping the bottle bagged and untouched. The night manager was asking if the footage was still recording.
If Nora had seen the act clearly, we had a witness. If she hadn't, we had two women telling stories that fit their own reasons for being near that table. Nora, who'd heard a phone call about money and decided to follow my bride. Vivian, who had a prescription bottle with no label and a financial motive my accountant had just laid out.
I opened the hallway door. Deputy Carson was there with his notepad, and behind him the ballroom doors were still closed with security standing shoulder to shoulder.
"We're going to need formal statements," Carson said, looking between me and Nora. "Both of them. Downtown. The lab will need hours on the glass anyway, and we can't hold a hundred guests here all night."
He wasn't asking.
Nora picked up her shoes again. She didn't look at me.
"Deputy," I said, "she just clarified she did not see the substance enter the glass. She saw a hand over the rim and a stirring motion. That's her statement."
Carson wrote it down word for word, and Nora didn't correct me.
May you like
"That's why we do interviews at the station," he said. He keyed his radio. "We need transport for two."
I stayed in the hallway as he walked back toward the ballroom to get Vivian. I didn't follow him. I didn't go tell my wife what Nora had just admitted. I stayed where I was and listened to the imperfect, too-loud hum of the recessed lights, and I tried to hold two equal doubts in my head at once without letting either one tip.
