Chapter 10
The house was too quiet with her gone. I dropped Ellie at school at 7:45 and watched her backpack disappear into the line of kids at the side entrance, her light pajamas long since traded for jeans and a pink coat. I sat in the parking lot after the bell rang and stared at the address my wife's aunt had texted me two years ago and I'd never used.
Diane lived twenty minutes out past the highway, in a one-story apartment behind the Save-A-Lot with a carport and wind chimes that didn't chime. I hadn't called first. I told myself if I called I'd talk myself out of it.
She opened the door before I knocked. She was smaller than I remembered, gray hair cut short, wearing a cardigan over a house dress. The TV was on low in the living room, a morning show I couldn't hear right.
"Well," she said. "You finally came."
The apartment smelled like coffee and laundry detergent. The walls were covered in photos I recognized and some I didn't. Diane moved slow to the kitchen and poured me a mug without asking how I took it. I sat at her little table and my hands wouldn't stop turning the mug around.
"I saw the sheriff's report," she said. "Your neighbor told me. Is Ellie alright?"
"She's at school," I said. "She's okay. Diane, I need to ask you about Jason."
Her hand paused on the counter. She didn't look surprised.
"So you know his name now," she said.
"He had a key to our house," I said. "Our house, Diane. Not a copied key. An original. Where did he get it?"
She sat down across from me and folded her hands. For a long second she just looked at me, and I realized she'd been waiting for this conversation since the funeral.
"That house was Carrie's before it was yours," she said. "You know that."
My wife, Carrie, had bought the hallway house before we married, with help from her grandmother. I'd always thought of it as ours.
"Carrie told me her brother wasn't in her life," I said. "She said he had problems. That it was better if he stayed away."
"He did have problems," Diane said. "And she did stay away. After Ellie was born."
She got up and pulled a shoebox off the top of the fridge. Inside were envelopes, some photos, a folded piece of paper that had been smoothed out too many times. She slid a photo toward me. Carrie at maybe twenty, arm around a younger version of the man who'd charged down my hallway. Long hair, no beard yet, same dark eyes. Both of them grinning on a lake dock.
"That's Jason," she said. "Her little brother. Two years younger. When their mom passed, it was just the two of them. He worshipped her."
I stared at the photo. The resemblance that had bothered me for a week suddenly made sense.
"What happened?" I asked.
"When Carrie got pregnant, Jason was in and out of rehab. He stole from her. Once from the baby's room, before Ellie even came home. Carrie changed the locks and told him he couldn't come around until he was clean for a year. He never made it a year." Diane's voice stayed flat, practiced. "After Carrie died, you kept that boundary for her. I get why you did. But Jason sees it different."
She pushed the folded paper across the table. It was a copy of a key-cut receipt from 2017, from Henderson Hardware on Main. The name on it was Carrie Miller. Two keys cut, house.
"She cut it for him," Diane said. "Right before Ellie was born. She was going to give it to him if he stayed clean thirty days. She told me. Then he showed up high that weekend and she never did. She kept the spare in her jewelry box. You must not have found it when you cleaned out her things."
I felt my stomach drop. I had cleaned out that jewelry box. I'd thrown a little tin of spare keys in a drawer in the laundry room and forgotten about it. Jason must have taken it when he came by for the memorial, when I'd let family walk through the house to take what they wanted.
"He thinks you knew," Diane said quietly. "He thinks you found that key and decided for Carrie that he would never be Ellie's uncle. That you erased him."
"I didn't know," I said. My voice sounded rough. "He never called. He never—"
"He did call," she said. "After Carrie died. I have the texts. He asked you three times to bring Ellie by my place so he could meet her in a neutral spot. You said no."
I remembered those texts now. Unknown number, six months after the funeral. I'd thought they were from some guy looking for money. I'd said we needed space. I'd blocked the number.
"I was trying to protect her," I said. "I was drowning, Diane. I didn't want anyone unstable near her."
"I know," she said. She reached across and put her hand over mine. Her hand was cold. "You protected her the way Carrie did. But Carrie was protecting her brother from himself until he got better. You protected her from her own family until there was no family left. That's not the same thing."
I looked again at the photo of Carrie and her brother on the dock, both laughing, before any of this existed. The key hadn't been a break-in. It had been a promise Carrie never got to decide whether to keep. And I'd held the door shut long after I should have asked why someone was knocking.
Diane slid another photo out. Jason holding Ellie in the hospital, hours after she was born. He was young, clean-shaven, crying.
May you like
"He was there that first day," she said. "Carrie let him. She wanted him to be her brother again."
I sat there with the coffee going cold, understanding finally that the man in my hallway hadn't come out of nowhere. He'd been waiting four years on the other side of a door I didn't know I'd locked.
