Chapter 3
He didn't come at me again right away. That was the strange part.
We stood maybe three feet apart, both breathing hard. His chest heaved under that dark jacket, his long hair stuck to his forehead with sweat. My hands were still up, one arm back around my daughter where she clutched my jeans. The hallway door behind him hung open a couple inches, letting in that cold draft from the entry. I could hear the house settling, the hum of the fridge from the kitchen, my own heart beating too loud in my ears.
He wiped his mouth with the back of his hand and stared at me. I stared back. For a second nobody moved. I'd expected him to lunge again, but he just stood there, breathing, like he was waiting for me to do something. My daughter's fingers tightened on my leg.
That's when I saw it.
On the wall to the left of the hallway, right beside the light switches, the thermostat glowed faint green. Seventy-one degrees. Below it, on the hardwood where the hallway met the living room rug, something caught the lamplight. Metal.
A key. A single brass house key on a plain silver ring, lying on its side just inside the door.
I knew that key.
We kept a spare under the fake rock by the front steps for my wife's mom, and one in the junk drawer in the kitchen. I'd seen them a hundred times. But this one wasn't supposed to be on the floor. The front door wasn't splintered. The jamb wasn't cracked. There was no kicked-in wood, no shattered glass. He hadn't broken in. He'd unlocked it.
My stomach dropped. I felt the shift before I could put words to it. This wasn't a burglary. This was someone who'd been given a way in.
I must have looked at it too long, because he followed my eyes down. He saw me see it. His mouth twitched, not quite a smile.
"You left it under the rock," he said, his voice low and rough from shouting. "You always leave it under the rock."
I didn't answer. I couldn't. My daughter was still pressed against me, her face hidden, but I felt her head tilt. She'd followed where I was looking too.
Behind me the lamp on the side table buzzed faintly. The fireplace was cold, the mantel dark above it. The bookshelf beside it stood exactly as it had that morning, but everything in the room felt off by an inch, like a picture hung crooked.
My daughter tugged once on my jeans.
"Daddy, do we know him?" she whispered.
Her voice was so small I almost didn't hear it. She wasn't crying. She was just asking, like she was asking about someone at the grocery store.
I should have told her the truth. I should have said his name. I should have said we did know him, that he used to sit at our kitchen table. Instead I looked down at her light brown hair, at her hands knotted in my henley, and I lied the only way I knew how in that moment. I just left the truth out.
"No, baby," I said. "Stay behind me, okay?"
It wasn't even a real answer. It was a dodge, and I heard it as soon as I said it. She nodded against my leg and held on tighter, and I felt the lie settle like something heavy in my chest.
He heard it too. He made a short, sharp sound, almost a laugh.
"No?" he said. "You're gonna do that? In front of her?"
I didn't look at him. I bent just enough to slide my foot forward, toeing the key while pretending to shift my weight. I nudged it, then stepped on it, felt the hard edge under my sock, then bent and palmed it in one quick motion like I'd dropped something. My hand closed around the cold metal. I slipped it straight into the front pocket of my jeans and kept my hand there.
My daughter didn't see. She was still tucked behind my knees, eyes on the hallway. But he saw. His eyes tracked my hand to my pocket and stayed there.
"That's my key," he said quietly. "You know that's my key."
I kept my hand in my pocket, fingers tight around it. The brass was warm from the floor heat now.
"It was under the rock," he said again. "She gave it to me. You know she did."
May you like
I didn't know what to say to that. I didn't know who she was in that sentence — my wife, or her mother — and I wasn't going to ask in front of my daughter. The hallway door eased open another inch on its hinges and clicked softly against the stop. The thermostat ticked as the heat kicked on, a small, ordinary click that sounded too loud in the quiet house.
I pulled my daughter a half-step back toward the sofa, putting the coffee table between us and him, and I didn't take my hand out of my pocket.
